Self-esteem

Perfectionism: stop judging yourself, not aiming high

You don't have to lower your standards, you have to drop the judgment: what a basketball coach and Fred Rogers teach about demanding a lot without wrecking yourself.

6 August 20266 min read
Lime green cover with the title on perfectionism and the GiddUP logo

Friday, 7 p.m. You've just sent the presentation to the client. The work is solid, and your manager has already written back: "Great job." You're rereading page three anyway, thinking: "I could have done better." It isn't the first time, and it's never really about the presentation. After every result the finish line slides a little further away, and you're left feeling permanently behind. That's perfectionism, and it has surprisingly little to do with wanting to be perfect.

Perfectionism isn't about wanting to be perfect

Ellen Hendriksen is a clinical psychologist at Boston University, and her book How to Be Enough starts right there: for the people who live with it, perfectionism isn't really about perfection. It's about never feeling good enough. From the outside you look like someone hitting every target. From the inside it feels like you're getting everything wrong.

The mechanism, which Hendriksen draws from the research of Roz Shafran and colleagues, is called overevaluation: how you rate yourself as a person depends on how you perform. It happens to the athlete who is only as good as their last game, and to anyone who measures a day by how much they got done.

So a mistake stops being a fact and becomes a verdict. Not "I wrote that email badly" but "something is wrong with me." If that sounds familiar, it's the same air you breathe with imposter syndrome: the successes are real, but they never quite convince you.

Why your inner critic feels useful

The voice that says "I could have done better" isn't a factory defect. Hendriksen explains why it feels useful: it keeps you alert, protects you from other people's criticism, stops you from getting a big head and from losing all motivation. Switch it off, you assume, and all that's left is laziness.

To take that idea apart, she uses an image. A grandfather in China, known as "Uncle Chen," went viral for running three marathons while chain-smoking, and he even finished in the top third of the field. Hendriksen's guess is that the training and the hard work are doing the job, not the cigarettes. Self-criticism works the same way: it steals the credit for your effort.

So if you take the self-criticism away, what's left? Not laziness. What's left is what the research calls excellence: the realistic, sustainable, healthy version of doing things well. For Hendriksen, the difference between excellence and perfectionism is criticism. A research team at Loughborough University found the same thing in exercise: what separates healthy exercise from perfectionistic exercise is self-criticism.

You don't have to stop evaluating yourself altogether, because a little self-judgment helps you correct course. The book asks a different question: does self-criticism give me more than it costs me? If the answer is no, you may need a different way of talking to yourself. It's the same trap we look at in our piece on willpower and being hard on yourself: harshness tends to end in giving up.

The coach who explained instead of judging

In 1965, on the first day of practice, UCLA coach John Wooden walks into the gym in front of a freshman team that includes Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, then still Lewis Alcindor. Everyone is waiting for a rousing speech. Instead he takes off his shoes and socks and shows them how to put them on, pulling until they fit snug.

Years later, researchers Ronald Gallimore and Roland Tharp studied UCLA's practices in the 1974/75 season. Praise and criticism were hot topics in education research at the time, and they were surprised: Wooden hardly used either. He taught. "Pass from the chest." "Don't walk." Three out of four of his comments were about the task, not the player. A highly successful football coach of the era was at 36 percent, and another well-regarded basketball coach at 55.

One of his players, Swen Nater, put it this way: if the corrections had been praise or criticism, he would have been left with "an evaluation, not a solution."

Hendriksen takes the idea off the court. "I suck" and "I'm not doing enough" are judgments that are personal, general and permanent. "Pass from the chest" is outside you, specific and fixable. And flipping the judgment to a positive one, "You've got this!", isn't enough: as long as you're evaluating yourself, you're still talking about you instead of the work.

Adam, at the end of an intensive coding course, would get stuck on a piece of code and end up furious with himself: "What's wrong with me?" He tried talking to himself like Wooden: "Try a flowchart." "Break the problem into tiny steps." "Take a break before you get mad." Quite a distance from where he started.

High standards yes, rigid rules no

Fred Rogers, the host of Mister Rogers' Neighborhood, was exacting to the point of obsession. Once, mid-shoot, he felt the script wasn't right. He stopped production, left the crew waiting on set, and walked over to consult his adviser, a child psychologist. An hour later he came back and filming resumed. For that show, excellence was the only acceptable standard.

And yet one day, during a taping, he buttoned his cardigan one button off: the Monday button in the Tuesday hole. The crew, who knew his standards, expected the usual "Cut, let's do it again." Instead he ad-libbed a line, re-buttoned the sweater, and showed that mistakes happen and can be fixed.

Hendriksen holds him up as someone who combines high standards with flexibility. Put simply: a rigid rule says "if I slip, I start over." A flexible standard says "I'll fix it and keep going." One wears you down. The other leaves you energy for the work that matters.

What to do today: change one sentence

You don't need to overhaul how you work. You need to change one sentence, once, today.

  1. Catch the verdict. Next time it shows up ("How stupid of me," "I could have done better"), stop for a second. That sentence is about you, not about the work.
  2. Turn it into an instruction. Ask what the work needs, the way a coach on the sideline would: "Start with an outline." "Reread just the numbers." "Ask a colleague to look at the draft."
  3. Make the first step tiny. Hendriksen describes a participant in a study she worked on who was trying to motivate himself to go to the gym. His first step was literally "peel a banana." If you feel any resistance, shrink the step a little more.

Friday, 7 p.m., again. The file is sent, and "I could have done better" shows up right on time. You can leave it there and ask yourself one question: what does this work need now? Your worth stays out of the equation.

GIDDUPonline

Is there something you don't do because you think you're not capable?

Tell me. We can start right from that little voice that keeps saying "you won't make it".